Glideworth and spreadsheets or free calculators compared
A dated, sourced comparison of Glideworth with FIRECalc, cFIREsim, FI Calc and spreadsheets: who each suits, what each does, price and moving over.
Facts about Spreadsheets and free calculators checked on . Products change; check the sources below for the latest.
Before a full planner, many people use a retirement calculator or a spreadsheet, and many keep using them. This page compares Glideworth with three web calculators (FIRECalc, cFIREsim and FI Calc), with the Bogleheads variable percentage withdrawal (VPW) worksheet, and with a spreadsheet you build yourself. Every statement about the three web calculators links to its page and the date we read it, 16 November 2026.
Who each suits
A calculator is the better choice if you have one question and want an answer in minutes. FIRECalc tests a spending plan against every historical start year since 1871 and reports how often it survived (FIRECalc, read 16 Nov 2026). cFIREsim offers a range of spending rules, including percent of portfolio, VPW, Hebeler Autopilot, Guyton-Klinger and Variable CAPE, and an “investigate” mode that finds the highest starting spending for a target success rate (cFIREsim, 16 Nov 2026). FI Calc backtests withdrawal strategies such as constant dollar, percent of portfolio, VPW, Guyton-Klinger, the 95% rule and Vanguard dynamic spending, and reports success rate, spending volatility and a per-simulation table (FI Calc, 16 Nov 2026). Glideworth needs you to describe a household before it answers anything.
A spreadsheet you build is the better choice if you want every formula in front of you and the freedom to model something unusual, and you are willing to maintain it. Nothing hides in a spreadsheet you wrote, and you can change any assumption in a cell.
Glideworth may suit you better if the question is bigger than “does this withdrawal rate survive?”: you want accounts, income, spending and milestones over decades in one plan, with tax estimated each year for each person, and the result shown as a year-by-year ledger. It also suits you if you want to branch a plan to compare changes, or reach the plan from scripts or an AI assistant.
Side by side
Each calculator cell links to its source and gives the date read. Glideworth cells describe the code in this repository today. A spreadsheet you build can do anything you put in it, so it has no fixed column.
| Glideworth | FIRECalc | cFIREsim | FI Calc | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Price | Self-hosted: free. Hosted: $9 a month or $90 a year, not live yet | Not stated on the page (FIRECalc, 16 Nov 2026) | Not stated on the page (cFIREsim, 16 Nov 2026) | Supported by donations (FI Calc, 16 Nov 2026) |
| History used | US history 1928 to 2025 or UK history 1983 to 2025; start years replayed or resampled | Every start year since 1871; data through 1 January 2026, updated 17 April 2026 (FIRECalc, 16 Nov 2026) | Most recent data stated as 1 August 2026 (cFIREsim, 16 Nov 2026) | Data source and date range not stated on the page (FI Calc, 16 Nov 2026) |
| Withdrawal rules | Initial percentage, ratcheting, VPW, Clyatt 95%, Guyton-Klinger, plus floor and ceiling; risk-based guardrails | Constant inflation-adjusted, Bernicke reduced spending, percent of portfolio, 95% rule (FIRECalc, 16 Nov 2026) | Inflation-adjusted, percent of portfolio, VPW, Hebeler Autopilot, Guyton-Klinger, Variable CAPE (cFIREsim, 16 Nov 2026) | Constant dollar, percent of portfolio, VPW, Guyton-Klinger, 95% rule, CAPE-based, Vanguard dynamic spending and more (FI Calc, 16 Nov 2026) |
| Tax | Estimated each year for each person in 12 countries, with a list of simplifications | No tax modelling mentioned (FIRECalc, 16 Nov 2026) | No tax model mentioned (cFIREsim, 16 Nov 2026) | No tax modelling mentioned (FI Calc, 16 Nov 2026) |
| Scope | A household of one or two people: accounts, real assets, debts, income, expenses, flows, milestones, branches | A spending plan tested against history, with Social Security and other income (FIRECalc, 16 Nov 2026) | Spending plan with allocation across equities, bonds, gold and cash, fees, rebalancing and glide path; up to two Social Security streams (cFIREsim, 16 Nov 2026) | Withdrawal strategy backtesting with asset mix and rebalancing (FI Calc, 16 Nov 2026) |
| Data and sharing | Self-hosted: stays on your machine. Hosted: not live yet | Says it does not store entered data (FIRECalc, 16 Nov 2026) | Not stated on the page (cFIREsim, 16 Nov 2026) | Share and export options (FI Calc, 16 Nov 2026) |
| Open source | Yes (AGPL-3.0) | Licence not stated on the page (FIRECalc, 16 Nov 2026) | Licence not stated on the page (cFIREsim, 16 Nov 2026) | Licence not stated on the page (FI Calc, 16 Nov 2026) |
Where the calculators are stronger
- Speed to an answer. You do not describe a household first.
- Rule variety on the page. cFIREsim and FI Calc list several withdrawal rules that Glideworth does not list by name, such as Hebeler Autopilot, Variable CAPE and Vanguard dynamic spending. Glideworth has guardrails and other rules, but not these.
- More recent data on the page. FIRECalc states data through 1 January 2026 and cFIREsim states 1 August 2026. Glideworth’s bundled US data ends in 2025 and is not updated automatically.
- No set-up. They run in a browser.
Where Glideworth does more
None of the three calculators describes tax modelling on the pages we read, or a household with several accounts and income streams over time. That is a gap in what those pages say, not proof the tools lack it. Glideworth also keeps a year-by-year ledger of every money movement, so you can see why a plan fails, where the money went in a year, and what edit explains a difference between two plans.
And a spreadsheet you build
A spreadsheet is the most flexible option and the cheapest to start. The cost shows later: you maintain the tax tables and update them when the law changes, build any Monte Carlo yourself, and carry the risk that a formula error goes unnoticed. Glideworth has tests for its engine and its tax tables, a list of what each country’s estimate leaves out, and an audit that flags common mistakes in a plan, but it is not error-free either.
Price
The three calculators’ pages we read state no price for FIRECalc or cFIREsim; FI Calc says it is supported by donations. cFIREsim’s page also offers a “try it free” link that refers to a separate product, so check each before you rely on it being free. Glideworth is free to self-host with every feature. The hosted service, Glideworth Cloud, is planned at $9 a month or $90 a year, after a 30-day trial without a card. The hosted service is not live yet; see pricing.
Moving over from a spreadsheet or calculator
There is no importer for a calculator or for a personal spreadsheet. You enter your household, accounts, income, spending and milestones, through the web app, the API or an AI assistant over MCP. If your spreadsheet holds balances in a layout like a bank or budgeting export, Glideworth’s generic CSV import may read it; check the dry-run report before you apply anything. If you have been using a calculator with a spending rule, you can set the matching rule in Glideworth if it is among those listed above, and compare the two answers before you trust either.
Expect different results. Glideworth’s default history is US 1928 to 2025, and it models returns, inflation and tax together in one run.
Questions
Is Glideworth a replacement for FIRECalc or cFIREsim?
Not necessarily. They answer a narrower question quickly. Glideworth answers a wider one, and takes longer to set up. Many people use a calculator to sense-check a plan.
Can I keep using a spreadsheet alongside Glideworth?
Yes. Glideworth exports JSON and CSV tables and has a REST API, so a spreadsheet or script can read from it.
Are the calculators free?
The pages we read stated no price for FIRECalc or cFIREsim, and FI Calc said it was supported by donations. Check each site for its current terms.
Where did these facts come from, and how do I report a mistake?
Every calculator statement links to its public page and the date it was read, 16 November 2026. Pages change, so a statement can go out of date. Email hello@glideworth.com with the page and what is wrong.
Sources
See where your plan lands.
Free to self-host today, with every feature. The hosted service opens later, at $9 a month or $90 a year.